Comparison · updated November 5, 2026

PeterMD vs Sesame Care: PeterMD for compounded medication, Sesame Care for brand-name medication

PeterMD and Sesame Care differ in what you pay, which medicines they list and their insurance terms. Compounded medicines are not FDA-approved.

These two prices are different kinds of bill, so read the line under each price before you compare them.

Compare plans and terms

PeterMD and Sesame Care pay us a commission when you join through our links. That never changes a score, an order or a fact on this page. How we make money

Which should you choose, PeterMD or Sesame Care?

Short answer: Choose PeterMD if you want a compounded medicine and accept that it is not FDA-approved. Choose Sesame Care if you want brand-name medicine rather than a compounded version.

Choose PeterMD if

  • you want a compounded medicine and accept that it is not FDA-approved

Choose Sesame Care if

  • you want brand-name medicine rather than a compounded version
  • you want a pill or another option without needles
  • you want to use insurance

The available assessments do not establish a score winner, so choose by the medicine, total cost and care you need.

By Iacob Pastina, Independent Researcher & Publisher
Reviewed & updated · Cites primary sources (FDA, NEJM, CMS) · Not medical advice

PeterMD vs Sesame Care side by side

PeterMD and Sesame Care compared fact by fact
PeterMDSesame Care
Pricefrom $149/mo$99/moProgram fee + medication; confirm monthly vs 28-day billing
MedicineCompounded onlyBrand-name only
Needle-free optionNot listedYes, a pill or other oral form
InsuranceNo insurance listedAccepts insurance
ConsultationIncludedVisits start at $34 on the homepage, with some services listed from $36; visits are included in the Success by Sesame subscription
ShippingIncludedNot published
Where it shipsAll states except AL, ID, AK and HI on the GLP1 plus B12 program and AL and ID on the tirzepatide page, while the intake form asks instead about Alabama, Arkansas, Idaho and Hawaii, so verify your state at signupNot confirmed: we could not verify which states Sesame Care serves
TrustpilotNot tracked4.6 / 5 across 4,533 reviews
BBB ratingA+ (accredited since August 10, 2026)A+
Our score6.5/10 Fair6.7/10 Fair
Assessment limitsChecked Oct 16, 2026; few independent reviews yet.Checked Oct 16, 2026; a rating claim didn't match Trustpilot.

What PeterMD and Sesame Care plans cost

PeterMD

Two compounded programs at two prices: GLP1 plus B12 from $149/mo, and tirzepatide plus B12 at $209/mo for any dose, with the page stating the price does not rise as your dose increases.

  • GLP1 + B12, Level 1$149Advertised at $149/Month and $447 total for an estimated 10 to 12 week supply, described on the product page as designed for first-time users
  • GLP1 + B12, Level 2$139Advertised at $139/Month and $834 total for an estimated 8 to 12 week supply, described on the product page as for current or returning users
  • Tirzepatide + B12, month one$109The tirzepatide plus B12 program page advertises $209/mo with $100 off your first month, so month one works out at $109
All 5 PeterMD plans
How PeterMD bills

The GLP1 plus B12 product page prices Level 1 at "$149/Month" and "$447 Total" for an estimated 10 to 12 week supply. Level 2 is labelled "$139/Month" and "$834 Total" for an estimated 8 to 12 week supply for current or returning users. These monthly labels and totals do not establish a monthly supply or when the next charge occurs. The separate tirzepatide plus B12 program advertises $209/mo for any dose with $100 off month one, and the tirzepatide page quotes $149 to start and $249 per month after that, billed quarterly at 60mg (verified 2026-09-03)

We checked PeterMD's prices on September 3, 2026.

Sesame Care

Provider choice, ongoing video care and medication prior-authorization help, with a separately priced brand-name GLP-1 menu and $59/mo advertised care on an annual commitment.

  • Success by Sesame (12-month plan)$59The $59/mo headline rate. The program page footnote reads "Based on a 12-month Success by Sesame commitment". Bundles provider visits, unlimited messaging and provider choice. Medication is separate.
  • Success by Sesame (6-month plan)$69Billed once every 6 months. The FAQ publishes this as a saving of $180 every 6 months against the $99 monthly rate, which works out near $69/mo. Medication is separate.
  • Success by Sesame (3-month plan)$79Billed once every 3 months. The FAQ publishes this as a saving of $60 every 3 months against the $99 monthly rate, which works out near $79/mo. Medication is separate.
All 9 Sesame Care plans
  • Success by Sesame (month-to-month)$99$99 program fee with no commitment; medication is separate. One program FAQ says billed every month, while another says every 28 days. Confirm the billing interval, your next payment date and how many charges you will pay in a year.
  • Single Consultation (pay-per-visit)$34One-off telehealth visit, no subscription required. The homepage says visits start at $34 and lists some services from $36.
  • Wegovy Pen (brand-name cash)$199Medication only: $199/month for the first two consecutive months at 0.25 or 0.5 mg for eligible new self-pay patients through December 31, 2026, then $349 for listed 0.25–2.4 mg doses. Care fees are separate
  • Wegovy Pill (oral semaglutide)$149Sesame lists $149/mo at 1.5 or 4 mg and $299 at 9 or 25 mg. Medication only; confirm current offer eligibility and add the separate care fee
  • Zepbound KwikPen (brand-name cash)$299The detailed menu lists $299 at 2.5 mg, $398 at 5 mg, $499 at 7.5 mg and $698 at 10–15 mg. A separate vial teaser also says from $299. Confirm the prescribed format and applicable manufacturer offer; care fees are separate
  • Foundayo (orforglipron oral)$149Medication only. Through December 31, 2026, Sesame's offer FAQ lists $149 at 0.8/2.5 mg, $199 at 5.5 mg and $299 at 9 mg. At 14.5/17.2 mg it lists $349, or $299 with Journey Program terms and refills within 45 days. The medication card shows higher non-promotional figures at some doses; confirm the applicable offer and add care fees
How Sesame Care bills

Program fee only. Medication is extra, so confirm the full bill. The program page says monthly in one FAQ and every 28 days in another. Confirm the billing interval and combined bill before paying.

We checked Sesame Care's prices on October 9, 2026.

What to watch for with PeterMD and Sesame Care

PeterMD

  • The excluded states differ by page: the GLP1 plus B12 program lists AL, ID, AK and HI, the tirzepatide page lists only AL and ID, and the intake form asks about Alabama, Arkansas, Idaho and Hawaii. Confirm your own state during signup before planning around PeterMD.
  • BBB opened PeterMD's file on July 28, 2026 and lists 22 complaints in the last three years, 12 of them in the last 12 months (checked October 16, 2026). Read them before you pay; a BBB grade measures complaint handling, not the quality of medical care.
PeterMD's strengths, cautions and terms

Strengths

  • The tirzepatide plus B12 program is one price for any dose, $209/mo, and the page says it does not go up as you titrate
  • B12 is listed as an added ingredient in the GLP1 + B12 program
  • Video consultations with physicians included, real face-to-face medical oversight

More to watch for

  • PeterMD began as a testosterone replacement therapy platform; GLP-1 is an expansion, not the original core. The included video consultations give you a direct read on the clinical team.
Medicines listed
  • Semaglutide + B12 (compounded, sold as the GLP1 + B12 program)
  • Tirzepatide + B12 (compounded)
Insurance
No insurance support listed
Consultation
Included
Shipping
Included
States
All states except AL, ID, AK and HI on the GLP1 plus B12 program and AL and ID on the tirzepatide page, while the intake form asks instead about Alabama, Arkansas, Idaho and Hawaii, so verify your state at signup (checked 2026-09-03)
Cancellation
Sales are generally final once medication is received. The policy offers replacement for damage or defects reported within 24 hours of receipt, while the acknowledgment mentions a defect-related refund exception; confirm the applicable remedy. For auto-renewing products, cancel by email at least 48 hours before renewal processing.

Sesame Care

  • Sesame runs three separate routes under one brand: the Success by Sesame weight loss subscription, EverydayRx for diabetes, and one-off visits from $34. Check which one you are signing up for before you pay.
  • The $59/mo Success by Sesame rate applies only on a 12-month commitment. The 3-month plan works out near $79/mo and the 6-month near $69/mo from the savings the FAQ publishes. For the $99 no-commitment plan, one FAQ says monthly and another says every 28 days. Confirm the interval and number of charges before budgeting for a year.
Sesame Care's strengths, cautions and terms

Strengths

  • Success by Sesame is $59/mo on the 12-month commitment and includes provider visits, unlimited messaging and provider choice; lab work is covered only at Quest Diagnostics and not in AZ, HI, ND, NJ, NY, OK, RI, SD or WY, where lab fees are extra; medication is separate
  • Published medication-only offers include eligible Wegovy pen starter doses at $199 for two months, then $349; the Wegovy pill and Zepbound KwikPen have dose-specific prices
  • Listed oral brands include Wegovy and Foundayo, with medication starting at $149 for eligible doses; the care fee is separate
  • Provider choice, ongoing video visits, messaging and app tools for weight, dose and side-effect tracking are described in the program

More to watch for

  • Sesame says compounded semaglutide is not currently available. Its published GLP-1 menu is brand-name; medication is billed on top of the program or visit fee.
  • Providers can set higher fees than the advertised program rate. Confirm the selected clinician's price and support arrangements before enrolling
Medicines listed
  • Wegovy (brand-name injection pen)
  • Wegovy (brand-name oral pill)
  • Ozempic (brand-name injection)
  • Zepbound (brand-name KwikPen/vial)
  • Mounjaro (brand-name injection)
  • Rybelsus (brand-name oral)
  • Foundayo (brand-name orforglipron oral, FDA-approved April 2026)
Insurance
Lists insurance support. Confirm coverage for your plan.
Consultation
Visits start at $34 on the homepage, with some services listed from $36; visits are included in the Success by Sesame subscription (verified 2026-09-03)
Shipping
Not published. A shipping cost is not shown on the site's weight loss program, medication or FAQ pages (rendered check 2026-09-03). Prescriptions are picked up at a local pharmacy or sent by home delivery, so any delivery charge comes from the pharmacy
States
Not confirmed: we could not verify which states Sesame Care serves. Confirm your state during sign-up.
Cancellation
You can self-cancel Success by Sesame at any time, and cancellation must happen before the next billing cycle starts to avoid the next charge. A full refund applies only if you cancel at least 3 hours before the initial visit, no refund is issued for the first month once that visit has happened, and fees for previous months are not refundable (verified 2026-09-03)

Compounded medicines are not FDA-approved, and the FDA does not review them for safety, effectiveness or quality before they are sold. Read the FDA's explanation of the risks.

PeterMD vs Sesame Care: common questions

Is PeterMD or Sesame Care cheaper?

At least one headline price is a starting, introductory, prepaid or partial figure, so neither is simply cheaper.

  • PeterMDfrom $149/mostarting price
  • Sesame Care$99/moprogram fee + medication; confirm monthly vs 28-day billing

Which is better, PeterMD or Sesame Care?

Neither wins outright on our scores, so the better one is the one that fits your medicine, budget and care needs.

PeterMD lists compounded medication only, and Sesame Care lists brand-name medication only. Sesame Care lists insurance support, and PeterMD does not.

Do PeterMD and Sesame Care offer brand-name medication?

PeterMD lists compounded medication only, and Sesame Care lists brand-name medication only.

Compounded medications are not FDA-approved. Your prescriber decides which medicine suits you.

Do PeterMD and Sesame Care take insurance?

Sesame Care lists insurance support, and PeterMD does not.

Confirm coverage for your exact plan and prescription before you pay.

Where these facts come from

PeterMD:prices checked September 3, 2026, score evidence assessed October 16, 2026.Read our PeterMD review

Sesame Care:prices checked October 9, 2026, score evidence assessed October 16, 2026.Read our Sesame Care review

We score on a published methodology, and partnership never changes a score or a fact here.

What should you compare next?